New evidence prompts review of nanny’s murder conviction in Martine case

Since 2006, law enforcement and the judicial system have been investigating the circumstances surrounding the death of one-year-old Martine. Her nanny, Rita, 54, was convicted in 2019 of murder for repeatedly striking Martine’s head against a hard surface, causing her death. However, Rita has consistently maintained her innocence and stated that she never harmed the child.

In 2023, the Review Commission decided that Rita would have another chance to present her case due to new evidence suggesting a reasonable possibility of acquittal had the court been aware of this information. The prosecution has requested that the appellate court review the case with input from five new experts before determining whether to proceed with a new trial or seek acquittal.

The case, often referred to as the “Nanny Case,” began when Martine was admitted to the hospital with severe injuries in 2006 and died four days later. Following an extensive investigation, which included being shelved twice due to inconclusive evidence, Rita was initially acquitted in 2018. However, after further investigation, she was later sentenced to four years in prison.

Rita’s defense attorney argues that the case is already well-established, with 17 experts previously consulted. He believes that additional evaluations may not be necessary, but they will comply with the appellate court’s decision. The key issue remains whether Martine’s injuries were sustained before or after her care began with Rita.

The new evidence consists of expert opinions reassessing the medical findings, with some suggesting that the injuries could have resulted from an accident rather than assault. The process continues with the hope of clarifying the details surrounding this tragic case.