Opens in a new tab

Appeal court says HKL could not cancel Siemens metro deals

Monday 16th November 2026 on 14:45 in Finland

Helsinki, metro, Siemens

Helsinki City Transport, the city’s public transport authority, had no right to cancel its contracts with Siemens to automate the Helsinki and West Metro lines, the Helsinki Court of Appeal has ruled. Yle reported that the decision reverses an earlier ruling by the district court.

The appeal court said delays to the automation project were mainly caused by factors for which HKL was responsible. HKL chief executive Saara Kanto said in a statement that the authority was “extremely disappointed”. HKL will review the interim judgment before deciding what to do next.

The ruling can be appealed to the Supreme Court. The appeal proceedings, which began in autumn 2024, are being handled in two stages. The court has now considered whether the contracts could be cancelled; compensation claims will be examined later.

HKL and Siemens agreed to automate the metro in 2008, but their cooperation soon ran into difficulties. In an interim ruling in 2020, the Helsinki District Court found that HKL had been justified in cancelling the automation contract.

In a separate 2021 ruling, the district court ordered Siemens to pay HKL more than 4.9 million euros in damages over the cancellation. Siemens was also ordered to refund just over three million euros for automation work on the metro and its depot. HKL was ordered to pay Siemens about 10,000 euros relating to automation of an extension to the depot. Siemens appealed, arguing that there had been no grounds to cancel the contracts.

Source 
(via Yle)