Appeal court upholds ruling against five-member family
Friday 20th November 2026 on 17:31 in
Iceland
Iceland’s Court of Appeal has upheld a ruling rejecting a five-member family’s applications for international protection and residence permits on humanitarian grounds, mbl.is reported. The family argued that shortcomings in the parents’ cooperation with authorities should not have led to the children’s applications being refused.
The family, whose members hold citizenship in both Syria and Venezuela, arrived from Venezuela and applied for international protection on 14 February 2023. The Directorate of Immigration rejected the applications in January 2024. The Immigration Appeals Board upheld that decision on 1 November 2024, more than 20 months after the applications were submitted.
Under the immigration law provision then in force, a humanitarian residence permit could be granted if no decision on an international protection application had been made at the administrative level within 18 months, or within 16 months for a child. Applicants also had to provide information and assistance in resolving their cases.
The family had passed those time limits when the appeals board ruled. However, the board found that the parents had not met the cooperation requirement, citing changes in their accounts of significant matters and concerns about the reliability of documents they submitted, in light of a police investigation. The Court of Appeal found that the family’s arguments and evidence did not undermine the board’s assessment.
The court said parents represent their minor children and are therefore responsible for providing information and assistance on their behalf. The appeals board had assessed the children’s circumstances separately, and the court found that the evidence indicated it was in their best interests to accompany their parents. One daughter turned 18 while the case was before the board, but it considered her young age and the court found no indication that a separate decision on her application would have changed the outcome.
The provision on residence permits for lengthy processing times was repealed in March. It still applies to applications that had reached the relevant time limit before the amendment took effect.