Committee says civil protection bill curbs municipal autonomy
Thursday 19th November 2026 on 23:45 in
Iceland
The Capital Region Civil Protection Committee says a proposed new Civil Protection Act would unduly restrict municipal autonomy, mbl.is reports. It objects in particular to a requirement that municipal emergency boards follow instructions from district-level incident command.
The committee supports a comprehensive revision of the law and welcomes the proposal to establish municipal emergency boards in legislation. Their role would include ensuring basic services continue during emergencies.
Under Article 32 of the bill, the boards would have to follow incident command instructions on measures to prevent or respond to danger. The committee says it is unclear when that duty would apply and which municipal responsibilities it could cover. It proposes instead that the boards coordinate their actions and share information, while municipal councils retain decision-making authority over their own duties.
The committee points to the evacuation of Grindavík residents and the coronavirus pandemic, saying crises can last months or years. During prolonged emergencies, municipalities must continue providing services including schools, social care and support for older people and people with disabilities. To do so, municipal councils need control over their staff and finances, the committee says, arguing that responsibility for services, decision-making authority and financial resources must go together.
It also wants municipalities explicitly listed as civil protection response bodies at national level. The bill says municipalities handle civil protection locally in cooperation with the state, but does not specifically name them among national response bodies. A general provision says that anyone given a role in a response plan is also considered a response body. The committee further wants a representative of the civil protection committee to retain a permanent seat on district-level incident command.
The bill gives police chiefs responsibility for both directing and coordinating civil protection operations locally. The committee says it is unclear how this would fit with fire chiefs’ legal authority over firefighting and the professional responsibilities within healthcare services. It proposes that police chiefs handle coordination, while each response body directs the tasks for which it is legally responsible. Police chiefs would still direct rescue teams during rescue, search and security operations on land, unless legislation assigns that authority elsewhere.
The committee supports a provision allowing the National Commissioner of Police to take necessary measures in an emergency to prevent imminent harm. It wants the law to specify that the danger must be real and imminent, less restrictive measures must be insufficient, and actions must not go beyond what is necessary. If measures affect municipal responsibilities, the municipality should be consulted before a decision is made, where circumstances allow.