Court voids 19 million króna offer for elderly man’s home
A court has voided a woman’s 19 million króna offer to buy the home of an elderly man who was living in a nursing home, mbl.is reported. It found that his ability to make an informed decision was significantly impaired and that the parties were in an unequal position.
The woman knew the man had given a relative authority to manage his finances, but negotiated directly with him without involving that representative. The court found she had shown some lack of care in making the agreement.
The woman offered to buy the approximately 104-square-metre terraced-house apartment in late July 2025. The man accepted on 4 August. The purchase price was to be paid when the contract was signed. Two nursing-home employees witnessed the signatures, the date and the parties’ competence. The man died on 31 October, aged 84.
His estate sued to have the offer set aside. The woman disputed the claim and filed a counterclaim seeking a deed transferring the property to her in return for payment. She said the man had wanted to sell, understood his decision and had not been pressured. She also said she had sought advice from a real estate agency about the apartment’s value.
The court considered evidence from a nursing-home nurse and department manager, including her testimony about the man’s declining health and cognitive abilities. There were no medical records, doctor’s certificate or court-appointed expert assessment of his condition when he accepted the offer. However, the court found the available evidence sufficient to assess his capacity. One of the three judges was a geriatrician.
Tests carried out in September and October 2025 indicated, in the court’s assessment, that the man’s cognitive impairment had reached the level of dementia. Given his medical history and the short time between the agreement and the tests, the court considered it highly likely that his capacity was similarly impaired when he accepted the offer in August.
The court did not find that the woman knew, or should have known, the extent of his cognitive impairment. Nor did it find that the difference between the apartment’s value and the agreed price was obvious. Two real estate valuations were submitted: one at 31 million króna and another at about 23 million. The latter was made without the agent inspecting the property. The court therefore did not set aside the offer on grounds of exploitation or dishonesty under contract law.
The judgment was issued on 9 November and published on Monday. The woman was ordered to pay the estate 1.4 million króna in legal costs.