Experts rate COP31 near rock bottom after talks fail
Sunday 22nd November 2026 on 22:01 in
Denmark
Three climate policy experts gave COP31 low marks after the UN climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, ended without an agreement, DR reported.
Danish Climate Minister Samira Nawa said she was “extremely disappointed” by what she called the collapse and chaos of the meeting. DR asked three experts to rate the summit on a scale from 1 to 10.
Jakob Dreyer: 1 out of 10
Jakob Dreyer, a researcher in international relations focusing on security and climate policy at the University of Copenhagen, gave COP31 a 1. He said the scale’s lowest point would be a total collapse, while the Paris Agreement rated 7 or 8.
Dreyer said it was the first time since the 2009 Copenhagen summit that a climate conference had ended without an adopted agreement. He also criticised the final draft for not mentioning fossil fuels and for being weak on climate science.
He said he did not give the summit zero because the Paris Agreement remains in place, and the EU and several island states had fought until the final moments to include a phase-out of fossil fuels. They rejected the draft when that effort failed.
Dreyer said global climate policy was in a deep crisis. With countries able to block consensus, he argued, those seeking action should pursue other routes, including coalitions of willing countries and green investment to support climate action, energy security and sustainability.
John Nordbo: 2 out of 10
John Nordbo, a climate adviser at the humanitarian organisation CARE, rated the summit 2 out of 10. It was his 20th COP meeting, and he said the result was close to a breakdown. He compared it with COP6 in The Hague in 2000, which ended without an agreement, and the 2009 Copenhagen summit, which he described as “a big chaos.”
Nordbo said what he called the EU’s “brutal” approach had hindered this year’s negotiations. He said the EU had previously sought support from poorer countries, but had instead come to the talks with a “power-holder approach” and demands about how things should be done.
He also pointed to Saudi Arabia. Oil-producing countries such as Saudi Arabia argue that Western countries are not providing enough climate compensation to countries suffering the worst effects of climate change, he said.
Mattias Söderberg: 2 out of 10
Mattias Söderberg, a climate adviser at Danish Church Aid who attended the summit in Antalya, also gave COP31 a 2. He rated the 2009 Copenhagen summit 2 and the 2015 Paris summit, where the Paris Agreement was adopted, 9.
Söderberg said he based his scores on what countries managed to deliver at each meeting. He cautioned against treating a poor summit result as proof that international cooperation had failed.
Although he was deeply disappointed, Söderberg said years of negotiations could still lead to breakthroughs. He pointed to the Paris Agreement, national climate plans and a fund for loss and damage as results achieved over time.
He said climate negotiations had become a mirror of the world’s political conflicts, making agreement harder but also showing the importance of climate policy.
The Paris Agreement is a legally binding climate pact adopted by UN member countries at COP21 in 2015. Its main goals include limiting global warming to well below 2 degrees Celsius and pursuing efforts to keep it to 1.5 degrees above pre-industrial levels.