The state should pay down debt, not run a bank

Saturday 21st November 2026 on 08:15 in Iceland

banking, Iceland, public finances

In an opinion article published by Morgunblaðið, Ásdís Kristjánsdóttir argues that Iceland should sell Landsbankinn and use the proceeds to reduce public debt rather than keep public money tied up in commercial banking.

Finance Minister has recently said he does not favour selling Landsbankinn because the state would lose future dividend payments. Others have called for a publicly run community bank to offer people more favourable loan terms. Kristjánsdóttir says both positions assume that hundreds of billions of krónur in taxpayer money should remain invested in ordinary banking, and questions whether that is a sound use of public funds.

Debt reduction has an opportunity cost

Future dividends should be reflected in the bank’s sale price, she argues. Keeping hundreds of billions of krónur invested in banking also has a significant opportunity cost: the state could instead use the proceeds from a sale to reduce debt, lower annual interest costs and improve its borrowing terms.

After accounting for lost dividends, the fiscal room created by reducing public debt could amount to about 10 billion krónur a year in the long term, she writes. The sale price would matter, but current dividend payments are not, in her view, sufficient reason for the state to operate the bank indefinitely.

Banking carries risks

Banks face risks through lending, funding and investments regardless of who owns them, Kristjánsdóttir says. The state’s role should be to ensure a trustworthy, secure and competitive financial system through regulation and oversight, rather than compete with private banks.

She says ordinary commercial banking is largely in private hands in many European countries. State ownership of banks is equivalent to about 1.9 per cent of gross domestic product in Norway, 0.4 per cent in Sweden and zero in Denmark, compared with around 7 per cent in Iceland.

Subsidised loans still have a cost

A community bank offering lower interest rates would not make those rates cost-free, she argues. If a state-owned bank lends below the level justified by its funding costs and credit risks, the resulting cost would show up as lower profitability, reduced dividends or greater risk. Ultimately, taxpayers would bear any cost that fell on the state.

Kristjánsdóttir cites the Housing Financing Fund, which was dissolved at significant cost to taxpayers. She also questions who should qualify for subsidised rates and how equal competition could be ensured. If the government wants to support particular groups, she says, it should do so transparently through the budget rather than through hidden subsidies in banking operations.

She argues that lower interest rates should be pursued through responsible economic management, lower inflation and healthy competition, rather than by increasing risks for taxpayers.

Source 
(via mbl.is)