University of Eastern Finland postpones doctoral defence over ethics concerns
Yle reports that the University of Eastern Finland has postponed a doctoral defence at short notice while it examines research ethics complaints about a thesis on mining disputes in Finland.
The thesis is by Toni Eerola, a senior specialist at the Geological Survey of Finland. The university has begun a preliminary assessment to decide whether the complaints warrant a full investigation. Professor emeritus Jukka Similä has been appointed to conduct the assessment.
Four complaints alleging breaches of good scientific practice had been filed after the thesis’s preliminary examination. They claim, among other things, that Eerola used research methods in a distorted way to serve his own aims. The complainants also allege that he held conflicting roles as an impartial researcher and an advocate for the mining industry. Some complaints concern his comments in social media groups discussing mining.
The complaints were filed by people known from citizen movements opposing mines. One is an associate professor of environmental policy. The thesis has already been published on the university’s publication platform.
Dean Matti Turtiainen described the case as unusual, saying he could not recall previous good scientific practice complaints at the university involving a doctoral thesis. He said the university would follow its normal procedures. Eerola declined to comment to Yle while the process is ongoing.
Taloussanomat first reported the case.