Finnish academic urges testing teachers as PISA scores fall
A Finnish education researcher says teachers should be tested to assess what they know, arguing that discussion of falling PISA scores has largely overlooked them. Yle reports that Kaisu Rättyä, a docent and university lecturer at Tampere University, believes there is already enough information about pupils’ performance.
Rättyä says a teacher’s knowledge is likely to have more influence on pupils’ learning than factors such as the school they attend or the size of their class. She wants more information about what teachers know, what they teach and how they teach it.
She also says decisions such as banning mobile phones in schools and increasing the use of digital teaching have given too little attention to teachers’ role. “It is a little like trying to remove fat and sugar from school meals while forgetting that the cook is the one who makes the food,” she said.
Economists have proposed trying mandatory national tests in comprehensive schools to gather more information about schools and the effects of changes made to them. In early November, Parliament approved a report by its Audit Committee recommending a trial. Education Minister Anders Adlercreutz voted against the proposal. Researchers have also debated whether national tests would do more harm than good.
Rättyä does not believe new mandatory tests for pupils would provide the information needed. Instead, she would examine local curricula and whether teachers have the knowledge to meet current needs. She says Finland’s national curriculum has expanded considerably over the past 20 years, including in mother tongue and literature.
Rättyä notes that the decline in PISA results began in 2006. She says this coincided with changes that placed greater emphasis on broad curriculum goals and reduced the focus on subject-specific knowledge.
A parliamentary report also proposed creating a register of teachers. Rättyä says such a register would show whether teachers hold the required qualifications, but not their actual level of knowledge.
Rättyä has trained subject teachers for nearly 20 years and says teacher education is too narrow. She argues that broader curricula require teachers to have broader knowledge and more time to study it. As an example, she says primary teacher education includes only five to 10 study credits each in literacy and mathematics as compulsory subjects.
She is also part of a research project examining curricula and textbooks. The project has found that the same topics can recur in textbooks across several grade levels, while content differs between books. In literary history, for example, some textbooks highlight Zacharias Topelius and others Johan Ludvig Runeberg, Rättyä said.