Opens in a new tab

Appeal court rejects mortgage backing rental company’s own purchase

Wednesday 18th November 2026 on 23:01 in Iceland

business, courts, Iceland

Iceland’s Court of Appeal ruled that a car rental company’s mortgage was not binding on its bankruptcy estate because it secured a loan used to buy the company, mbl.is reported.

The court upheld two Reykjavik District Court rulings that denied security rights to claims held by two funds managed by Kvika Asset Management in the bankruptcy of Bílaleiga Reykjavíkur. The claims against the company’s buyer, Bergmál fjárfestingar, totalled ISK 194.5 million when the rental company entered bankruptcy proceedings in May 2024. A total of ISK 20 million was later paid toward them.

The dispute concerned whether the funds had a mortgage over a property at Arnarvellir 4 in Suðurnesjabær, or over its sale proceeds. Kvika must pay the bankruptcy estate ISK 7.5 million in legal costs across both court levels.

The company pledged its property

Bergmál fjárfestingar borrowed ISK 175 million from GAMMA Credit Opportunity Fund to buy Bílaleiga Reykjavíkur in 2017. The fund is now called Credit Opportunity Fund and is managed by Kvika Asset Management.

Under the financing agreement, the rental company was to pledge the Arnarvellir 4 property as security for the loan. It issued a security instrument for ISK 190 million. When the loan was refinanced in 2020, Bergmál issued two bonds, one to Credit Opportunity Fund and the other to Kvika Domestic Bond Fund. The 2017 security instrument was intended to cover both bonds.

Sale agreement was never completed

Kvika argued that Bergmál had already acquired the property when it was mortgaged, citing a purchase agreement the companies had made less than a month before the loan was issued.

The Court of Appeal found that the agreement gave Bergmál a conditional ownership right, but that Bílaleiga Reykjavíkur remained the property’s owner. Bergmál never completed the purchase, the agreement was not registered, and no deed of conveyance was issued. The security instrument named the rental company as both owner and mortgagor.

The court therefore found that the rental company had provided security to finance the purchase of shares in itself. It ruled that the specific prohibition in the law on private limited companies against this kind of financing took precedence over the general permission for a company to guarantee its parent company’s obligations.

A lawyer acting for the lender had warned that the mortgage might breach the law. The lender did not confirm that ownership had fully transferred to Bergmál, and structured the security on the assumption that the rental company still owned the property. The court concluded that the mortgage was not binding on the bankruptcy estate.

The Court of Appeal agreed with the District Court on the validity of the mortgage but differed on the burden of proof. Kvika had provided evidence of the claims and shown that the mortgage was intended to secure them, so the estate had to prove that the mortgage was invalid. The court found that it had done so.

Source 
(via mbl.is)