Supreme Court rejects injunction against Papco’s rubbish bags
Wednesday 18th November 2026 on 17:31 in
Iceland
Iceland’s Supreme Court has rejected an injunction against Papco’s production and sale of rubbish bags labelled “STERKIR”, ruling that customers were not shown to be at risk of confusing them with Samhentir Kassagerð’s bags. The ruling was reported by mbl.is.
The court overturned a Court of Appeal ruling from June last year, which had upheld the injunction under the law on business practices and marketing. A district court had previously ruled in Papco’s favour.
Samhentir has sold rubbish bags labelled “STERKUR” for years. The Supreme Court said the word describes the bags’ strength and lacks distinctive character on its own. However, Samhentir’s full mark, which combines the word with the company name and logo, qualifies for trademark protection. That protection applies to the mark as a whole.
In assessing the risk of confusion, the court said the company names were clearly shown on the bags. The similarity between “STERKUR” and “STERKIR” carried less weight because both words describe the bags’ strength. The court also noted that the typeface is common on packaging and that other companies sell bags of the same size with similar colour markings.
Papco had previously sold Samhentir bags before starting to sell its own bags labelled “STERKIR”. In August 2023, a Samhentir employee ordered bags through Papco’s online store after they were advertised as Samhentir products, but received bags marked with Papco’s name. Papco said it had failed to update the online images after it stopped selling Samhentir bags.
The District Commissioner of the Capital Region imposed an injunction in October 2023 on Papco’s production, import, distribution and sale of the bags. Samhentir then went to court to have the injunction upheld and to prevent Papco from using the marking. The Supreme Court said the mistaken delivery and Papco’s earlier resale of Samhentir bags did not establish a risk that customers would confuse the products.
The court also found no evidence that “STERKUR” had become so well known through use that customers associated the word alone with a particular producer. Samhentir was ordered to pay Papco a total of four million krónur in legal costs across the three court levels. Papco has labelled its bags “TRAUSTIR” since the injunction was imposed.